Natural Resources
Conservation Service

Ecological site R052XC204MT

Claypan (Cp) 10-14" p.z.

Last updated: 1/24/2024
Accessed: 11/21/2024

Home / Esd catalog / MLRA 052X / Ecological site R052XC204MT

USC

Metric

General information

Provisional. A provisional ecological site description has undergone quality control and quality assurance review. It contains a working state and transition model and enough information to identify the ecological site.

MLRA notes

Major Land Resource Area (MLRA): 052X–Brown Glaciated Plains

The Brown Glaciated Plains, MLRA 52, is an expansive and agriculturally and ecologically significant area. It consists of around 14.5 million acres and stretches across 350 miles from east to west, encompassing portions of 15 counties in north-central Montana. This region represents the southwestern limit of the Laurentide Ice Sheet and is considered to be the driest and westernmost area within the vast network of glacially-derived prairie pothole landforms of the northern Great Plains. Elevation ranges from 2,000 feet (610 meters) to 4,600 feet (1,400 meters).

Soils are primarily Mollisols but Entisols, Inceptisols, Alfisols and Vertisols are also common. Till from continental glaciation is the predominant parent material, but alluvium and bedrock are also common. Till deposits are typically less than 50 feet thick, and in some areas glacially deformed bedrock occurs at or near the soil surface (Soller, 2001). Underlying the till is sedimentary bedrock largely consisting of Cretaceous shale, sandstone and mudstone (Vuke et al. 2007). It is commonly exposed on hillslopes, particularly along drainage ways. Significant alluvial deposits occur along glacial outwash channels and major drainages, including portions of the Missouri, Teton, Marias, Milk, and Frenchman Rivers. Large glacial lakes, particularly in the western half of the MLRA, deposited clayey and silty lacustrine sediments (Fullerton et al. 2013).

Much of the western portion of this MLRA was glaciated towards the end of the Wisconsin age, and the maximum glacial extent occurred approximately 20,000 years ago (Fullerton et al., 2004). The result is a geologically young landscape that is predominantly a level till plain interspersed with lake plains and dominated by soils in the Mollisol and Vertisol orders. These soils are very productive and generally are well-suited to dryland farming. Much of this area is aridic-ustic. Crop-fallow dryland wheat farming is the predominant land use. Areas of rangeland typically are on steep hillslopes along drainages.

The rangeland, much of which is native mixed grass prairie, increases in abundance in the eastern half of the MLRA. The Wisconsin-age till in the north-central part of this area typically formed large disintegration moraines with steep slopes and numerous poorly-drained potholes. A large portion of Wisconsin-age till occurring on level terrain that would typically be optimal for farming has large amounts of less-suitable sodium-affected Natrustalfs. Significant portions of Blaine, Phillips, and Valley Counties were glaciated approximately 150,000 years ago during the Illinoisan age. Due to erosion and dissection of the landscape, many of these areas have steeper slopes and more exposed bedrock than areas glaciated during the Wisconsin age (Fullerton and Colton, 1986).

While much of the rangeland in the aridic-ustic portion of MLRA 52 is classified as belonging to the - “dry grassland” - climatic zone, sites in portions of southern MLRA 52 may belong to the -“dry shrubland” - climatic zone. The dry shrubland zone represents the northernmost extent of the big sagebrush (Artemisia tridentata) steppe on the Great Plains. Because similar soils occur in both southern and northern portions of the MLRA, it is currently hypothesized that climate is the primary driving factor affecting big sagebrush distribution in this area. However the precise factors are not fully understood at this time.

Sizeable tracts of largely unbroken rangeland in the eastern half of the MLRA and adjacent southern Saskatchewan are home to the Northern Montana population of greater sage grouse (Centrocercus urophasianus), and large portions of this area are considered to be a Priority Area for Conservation (PAC) by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, 2013). This population is unique among sage grouse populations because many individuals overwinter in the big sagebrush steppe (dry shrubland) in the southern portion of the MLRA and then migrate to the northern portion of the MLRA, which lacks big sagebrush (dry grassland), to live the rest of the year (Smith, 2013).

Areas of the till plain near the Bearpaw and Highwood Mountains as well as the Sweetgrass Hills and Rocky Mountain foothills are at higher elevations, receive higher amounts of precipitation, and have a typic-ustic moisture regime. These areas have significantly more rangeland production than the drier aridic-ustic portions of the MLRA and have enough moisture to produce crops annually rather than just bi-annually, as in the drier areas. Ecological sites in this higher precipitation area are classified as the moist grassland climatic zone.

Classification relationships

NRCS Soil Geography Hierarchy
• Land Resource Region: Northern Great Plains
• Major Land Resource Area (MLRA): 052 Brown Glaciated Plains
• Climate Zone: Dry Grassland

National Hierarchical Framework of Ecological Units (Cleland et al., 1997; McNab et al., 2007)
• Domain: Dry
• Division: Temperate Steppe
• Province: Great Plains-Palouse Dry Steppe Province 331
• Section: Northwestern Glaciated Plains 331D
• Subsection: Montana Glaciated Plains 331Dh
• Landtype association/Landtype phase: N/A

National Vegetation Classification Standard (Federal Geographic Data Committee, 2008)
• Class: Mesomorphic Shrub and Herb Vegetation Class (2)
• Subclass: Temperate and Boreal Grassland and Shrubland Subclass (2.B)
• Formation: Temperate Grassland, Meadow, and Shrubland Formation (2.B.2)
• Division: Great Plains Grassland and Shrubland Division (2.b.2.Nb)
• Macrogroup: Hesperostipa comata – Pascopyrum smithii – Festuca hallii Grassland Macrogroup (2.B.2.Nb.2)
• Group: Pascopyrum smithii – Hesperostipa comata – Schizachyrium scoparium – Bouteloua spp. Mixedgrass Prairie Group (2.B.2.Nb.2.c)
• Alliance: Pascopyrum smithii – Nassella viridula Northwestern Great Plains Herbaceous Alliance
• Association: Pascopyrum smithii –Bouteloua gracilis – Carex filifolia Herbaceous Vegetation

EPA Ecoregions
• Level 1: Great Plains (9)
• Level 2: West-Central Semi-Arid Prairies (9.3)
• Level 3: Northwestern Glaciated Plains (42)
• Level 4: North Central Brown Glaciated Plains (42o) & Glaciated Northern Grasslands (42j)

Ecological site concept

The distinguishing characteristic of this site is the presence of a dense, sodium-affected (natric) horizon between depths of 5 to 10 inches from the surface. The natric horizon exhibits columnar structure, is very hard, and severely limits both root penetration and infiltration. Soil surface horizons (0 to 4 inches) are very fine sandy loam to loam, and the natric horizon is clay or clay loam. The root-restrictive natric horizon favors shallower-rooted rhizomatous species, particularly the rhizomatous wheatgrasses, over deep-rooted bunchgrasses.

Associated sites

R052XC205MT	Clayey (Cy) 10-14" p.z. soils >20 inches in depth, higher production, and no hardpan, different species composition
R052XC216MT	Shallow to Gravel (SwGr) 10-14" p.z. similar position in landscape, soils with depth restriction that limits available moisture, soils 10-20” deep to sands or loamy sands
R052XC215MT	Shallow Clay (SwC) 10-14" p.z. soils 10-20” deep to bedrock’ soils are clayey over clayey shale
R052XC206MT	Dense Clay (DC) 10-14" p.z. has less than 2” of soil over the hard argillic layer, more bare ground, and less production
R052XC210MT	Saline Upland (SU) 10-14" p.z. does not have a very hard layer near surface, plant community contains salt- tolerant species

Similar sites

R052XN086MT	Claypan (Cp) 10-14" p.z. May have increase in total annual production of bluebunch wheatgrass.
R053AE074MT	Claypan (Cp) (Legacy) RRU 53AE May have decrease in total annual production of bluebunch wheatgrass, and an increase in other wheatgrasses and/or needlegrass.

R052XN086MT

Claypan (Cp) 10-14" p.z.

May have increase in total annual production of bluebunch wheatgrass.

R053AE074MT

Claypan (Cp) (Legacy) RRU 53AE

May have decrease in total annual production of bluebunch wheatgrass, and an increase in other wheatgrasses and/or needlegrass.

Table 1. Dominant plant species

Tree	Not specified
Shrub	(1) Atriplex nuttallii (2) Artemisia cana
Herbaceous	(1) Pascopyrum smithii (2) Nassella viridula

Download full description

Physiographic features

This ecological site occurs on level to sloping glaciated plains, stream terraces and fans. Slopes vary from 0 to 15 percent, but are usually less than 8 percent. This site occurs on all exposures. Elevations normally vary from 2000 to 4000 feet, but this ecological site has a slightly larger range.

Table 2. Representative physiographic features

Landforms	(1) Plains > Plain (2) Plains > Stream terrace (3) Plains > Fan
Runoff class	Medium to very high
Flooding frequency	None
Ponding frequency	None
Elevation	572 – 1,463 m
Slope	0 – 15%
Aspect	W, NW, N, NE, E, SE, S, SW

Climatic features

A semi-arid, temperate climate characterizes the Glaciated Plains. The predominance of cool season species has evolved to take advantage of the precipitation regime that peaks in late spring-early summer (June). Seventy-five percent of the annual precipitation usually falls as steady, soaking, frontal system rains. Summer rains usually come with thunderstorms. Precipitation is the most important factor influencing production (Heitschmidt et al 2005). Severe drought occurs on average in two out of every ten years (Cooper, et al., 2001).

Table 3. Representative climatic features

Frost-free period (characteristic range)	85-123 days
Freeze-free period (characteristic range)	116-142 days
Precipitation total (characteristic range)	254-356 mm
Frost-free period (average)	94 days
Freeze-free period (average)	125 days
Precipitation total (average)	305 mm

Characteristic range

Actual range

Bar

Line

Figure 1. Monthly precipitation range

Characteristic range

Actual range

Bar

Line

Figure 2. Monthly minimum temperature range

Characteristic range

Actual range

Bar

Line

Figure 3. Monthly maximum temperature range

Bar

Line

Figure 4. Monthly average minimum and maximum temperature

Figure 5. Annual precipitation pattern

Figure 6. Annual average temperature pattern

Climate stations used

(1) CHESTER [USC00241692], Chester, MT
(2) GLASGOW [USW00094008], Glasgow, MT
(3) HAVRE CITY CO AP [USW00094012], Havre, MT
(4) SHELBY [USC00247500], Shelby, MT

Soil features

These deep and very deep, well drained soils formed in glacial till. Soils occupy glacial uplands. The surface layer varies from 2 to 8 inches in depth, and has a clay loam to fine sandy loam texture. The B horizon is characterized by a hard argillic horizon (6 to 10 inches thick), which restricts root penetration. The argillic layer has strong columnar structure. Salt accumulations are often visible in the lower part of the B horizon. These soils are usually very hard when dry and very sticky when wet.
Permeability is very slow. Soil ph varies from 6.6 to 9.0. This site is characterized by the following soil components: Gerdrum, Archin, Elloam and Thoeny.

Table 4. Representative soil features

Parent material	(1) Till – sedimentary rock (2) Glaciofluvial deposits
Surface texture	(1) Loam (2) Fine sandy loam (3) Clay loam
Family particle size	(1) Fine
Drainage class	Well drained
Permeability class	Very slow
Soil depth	51 – 183 cm
Available water capacity (Depth not specified)	10.16 – 12.7 cm
Calcium carbonate equivalent (Depth not specified)	0 – 10%
Electrical conductivity (Depth not specified)	0 – 16 mmhos/cm
Sodium adsorption ratio (Depth not specified)	5 – 25
Soil reaction (1:1 water) (Depth not specified)	6.6 – 9
Subsurface fragment volume <=3" (Depth not specified)	5 – 15%
Subsurface fragment volume >3" (Depth not specified)	0 – 2%

Ecological dynamics

This site developed through time under the influence of climate, geological materials, fire, plants and animals. Research consistently shows that precipitation is the principal factor altering productivity on ecological sites in the Northern Great Plains (Heitschmidt et al. 2005). The same authors concluded that grazing reduces herbage standing crop, whereas its effects on above ground net primary production varies with timing of grazing and precipitation events, along with the functional and structural composition of the plant community.
It is theorized that these lands burned on a natural interval of 10-12 years (Frost 1998). However, environmental characteristics of this site limit herbage production and subsequent fuel accumulation. Therefore, in comparison to other upland ecological sites, the role of natural fire is probably less significant in the development of this site.
The resultant historic climax plant community (HCPC) is the basis for plant community interpretations. The HCPC has been determined by evaluating rangeland relic areas, and other areas protected from excessive disturbance.
The HCPC is comprised of a mixture of cool and warm season grasses and shrubs. About 85% of the annual production is from grasses and sedges, most of which is produced during the cool season. Forbs and shrubs contribute 5 and 10 percent, respectively, to total annual production. Total vegetative production averages 900 pounds per acre in normal years, 500 pounds per acre in “unfavorable” years, and 1200 pounds per acre in “favorable” years.
This site is moderately resilient to disturbance because soil characteristics limit plant growth. Departures from the HCPC generally result from management actions, drought, and/or a change in the natural fire regime. The site is considered fragile in the sense that vegetative vigor and composition will rapidly decline in the absence of prescribed grazing and during prolonged drought. With favorable precipitation and/or prescribed grazing treatments, the plant community can return to the HCPC. However, succession may be slow. Trends in plant community dynamics, states, transitional pathways, and thresholds have been evaluated and determined through experience and research.
Successional pathways of the Clay Pan 10-14” p.z. ecological site cannot be satisfactorily described using traditional theories of plant succession leading to a single climax community (Briske et al. 2005). As the HCPC regresses to an early seral state, it is theorized that a threshold is crossed somewhere within the mid-seral state. Plant communities occurring below this threshold are in a steady state. Succession back to the HCPC does not occur within a reasonable length of time, and/or without a large input of energy.
Three plant communities and the successional pathways that commonly occur within the Reference State (State 1) are shown in the following diagram. In addition, the transition from State 1 to State 2 and a representative plant community in the latter state are also illustrated. Ecological processes are discussed in the plant community descriptions following the diagram.

State and transition model

Custom diagram

Standard diagram

More interactive model formats are also available. View Interactive Models

More interactive model formats are also available. View Interactive Models
Click on state and transition labels to scroll to the respective text

Ecosystem states

1. State 1: Reference State

2. State 2: Plant Community C

T1A	-	Non-prescribed grazing, no fire, and extended drought (>7 years)
R2A	-	Prescribed grazing, fire (natural interval 10 to 12 years), prolonged favorable precipitation

State 1 submodel, plant communities

1.1. Reference Plant Community

1.2. Plant Community A

1.3. Plant Community B - Pre-Threshold Community

CP 1.1 - 1.2	-	No fire, no prescribed grazing, and drought (3 to 5 years)
CP 1.2 - 1.1	-	Fire (Natural Interval 10 to 12 years), Prescribed grazing
CP 1.2 - 1.3	-	No fire, no prescribed grazing, prolonged drought (5 to 7 years)
CP 1.3 - 1.2	-	Fire (Natural interval 10 to 12 years), prescribed grazing, favorable precipitation

State 2 submodel, plant communities

2.1. State 2; Plant Community C

State 1
State 1: Reference State

Community 1.1
Reference Plant Community

Mid and Tall Cool Season Perennial Grasses; Cool and Warm Season Perennial Grasses; 5 percent Native Forbs, and 10 percent Native Shrubs.

Resilience management. Western/thickspike wheatgrass, bluebunch wheatgrass and green needlegrass are common cool season mid grasses on this ecological site. Alkali sacaton, a tall warm season grass occurs on this site in the eastern glaciated plains. These high-successional grasses account for about 75 percent of total plant production in the HCPC. Needle and thread, another cool season mid grass is common and tends to replace the green needlegrass when it is stressed by lack of moisture, grazing or etc. About 10 percent of the total production is comprised of a mix of warm and cool season short grasses and grasslike plants. These species include: blue grama, sandberg bluegrass, plains reedgrass, prairie junegrass, needleleaf sedge, and threadleaf sedge. American vetch, a cool season, nitrogen-fixing legume is one of the most important members of the forb community. White and purple prairie clover are important warm season legumes. Additional nitrogen is fixed by lower successional legumes (milkvetches, scurfpeas, and prairie thermopsis). Onion, hoods phlox, scarlet globemallow, wooly plantain, and biscuitroot often occur in the HCPC. The latter group contains a mix of warm and cool season species whose relative occurrence on the site is largely influenced by the timing and amount of precipitation. Forbs contribute about 5 percent of the total annual production. Nuttall saltbush, greasewood and silver sagebrush are the most important browse species occurring on this site. While the former two species make their major growth and flower during the cool season, silver sagebrush is a warm season species. Shrubs such as big sagebrush and prickly pear cactus may occur in some areas. Fringed sagebrush, a half-shrub may also be found in the HCPC. Shrubs normally make up about 10 percent of the total annual production. Broom snakeweed, annual bromes, and annual forbs are not a part of the HCPC. Their presence indicates possible ecological deterioration, or downward trend. Trend is difficult to interpret because large areas of bare ground between plants are fairly common. Total annual production within the HCPC averages 900 pounds per acre during normal years. Thus production is 300 pounds per acre higher than it is on the Dense Clay 10-14” p.z. ecological site, and 400 pounds per acre less than on the Clayey 10-14” p.z. ecological site. Production declines as the HCPC regresses from the HCPC to lower successional communities. Regression may result from grazing management strategies that do not allow adequate recovery periods between grazing events, drought, and/or the disruption of the normal fire sequence. The above disturbances favor the replacement of green needlegrass, bluebunch wheatgrass, and western/thickspike wheatgrass by needle and thread, blue grama, sandberg bluegrass, prairie junegrass, hairy goldenaster, and hood's phlox. Nuttall saltbush may also be replaced by broom snakeweed, fringed sagewort, etc. Cheatgrass and Japanese brome may invade the site. As the result of these vegetative changes, there is less litter to protect the soil and less infiltration. Hydrologic cycles are impaired when plant communities are unable to effectively use precipitation. Plant basal cover varies from 7 to 20 percent. Litter varies from 40 to 50 percent, and bare ground ranges from 25 to 45 percent. Thus, surface runoff and erosion are potential concerns on the Clay Pan 10-14” p.z. ecological site. Runoff and soil erosion increase as the HCPC regresses to earlier seral states.

Dominant plant species

Nuttall's saltbush (Atriplex nuttallii), shrub
silver sagebrush (Artemisia cana), shrub
western wheatgrass (Pascopyrum smithii), grass
thickspike wheatgrass (Elymus lanceolatus ssp. lanceolatus), grass
bluebunch wheatgrass (Pseudoroegneria spicata), grass
green needlegrass (Nassella viridula), grass

Figure 7. Annual production by plant type (representative values) or group (midpoint values)

Table 5. Annual production by plant type

Plant type	Low (kg/hectare)	Representative value (kg/hectare)	High (kg/hectare)
Grass/Grasslike	476	857	1143
Shrub/Vine	56	101	135
Forb	28	50	67
Total	560	1008	1345

Table 6. Ground cover

Tree foliar cover	0%
Shrub/vine/liana foliar cover	0%
Grass/grasslike foliar cover	0%
Forb foliar cover	0%
Non-vascular plants	0-1%
Biological crusts	0-1%
Litter	15-40%
Surface fragments >0.25" and <=3"	0-1%
Surface fragments >3"	0-1%
Bedrock	0-1%
Water	0%
Bare ground	10-20%

Table 7. Soil surface cover

Tree basal cover	0%
Shrub/vine/liana basal cover	1-5%
Grass/grasslike basal cover	10-15%
Forb basal cover	1-2%
Non-vascular plants	0%
Biological crusts	0%
Litter	0%
Surface fragments >0.25" and <=3"	0%
Surface fragments >3"	0%
Bedrock	0%
Water	0%
Bare ground	0%

Table 8. Canopy structure (% cover)

Height Above Ground (m)	Tree	Shrub/Vine	Grass/ Grasslike	Forb
<0.15	–	0-1%	5-20%	5-25%
>0.15 <= 0.3	–	10-40%	20-40%	0-50%
>0.3 <= 0.6	–	0-50%	0-25%	0-25%
>0.6 <= 1.4	–	0-10%	0-15%	–
>1.4 <= 4	–	–	–	–
>4 <= 12	–	–	–	–
>12 <= 24	–	–	–	–
>24 <= 37	–	–	–	–
>37	–	–	–	–

Community 1.2
Plant Community A

Reduced production; Mid and Tall Cool Season Perennial Grasses; Cool and Warm Season Short Grasses 5 percent Forbs; and 10 percent shrubs.

Resilience management. Total annual production is about 80% of the HCPC. Western and thickspike wheatgrasses, and green needlegrass still contribute approximately 60 percent of the annual production. However, they are less vigorous and individual plant growth is reduced from what it is in the HCPC. The short grass production increases in comparison to the HCPC. Plant height and plant litter are reduced while bare ground increases. Surface runoff and soil temperature increases, infiltration decreases, and shallow-rooted short grasses and sedges gain a competitive advantage over medium height, deep-rooted cool season perennial grasses. They are able to compete more successfully with the mid-grasses because of the ability of relatively shallow root systems to utilize shallowly penetrating moisture, characteristic of this site. Total shrub production continues to represent about 5 percent of total annual production. However, vigor of the prairie clovers and American vetch has decreased relative to the vigor of hoods phlox and other low-successional forbs. Total shrub production remains at about 10 percent of the total annual production.

Community 1.3
Plant Community B - Pre-Threshold Community

Lower production; Mid Cool Season Perennial Grasses; Short Cool and Warm Season Perennial Grasses; Increase of Lower Successional Forbs and Half-shrubs

Resilience management. This Community is dominated by a mix of medium and short grasses. Blue grama, threadleaf sedge, needle and thread and sandberg bluegrass increased in the community by replacing some of the mid grasses. However, western and thickspike wheatgrass and green needlegrass continue to contribute nearly 50 percent of the total annual production. In comparison to Community A, the short grasses contain more blue grama, a warm season species. Sand dropseed and tumblegrass may also begin to appear in the community. Warm season forbs increase and replace American vetch and other high-successional forbs. The warm season half-shrub, fringed sagewort, increases in production. Pricklypear cactus and broom snakeweed are conspicuous in this community. Annual production is 40 to 60 percent of potential for the site. Plant species in this community tend to exhibit more salt tolerant characteristics than the species found in the HCPC or Community A. Infiltration is moderately reduced due to adverse changes in plant community composition and/or distribution. The amount of bare ground is moderately higher than expected for this site (bare ground equal to 45 to 60 percent). In comparison to the HCPC, total plant cover varies from 30 to 40 percent. Litter is reduced to 10 to 15 percent, which is moderately less, relative to site potential and weather. Active rill formation is slight at infrequent intervals, mostly in exposed areas. Water flow patterns match what is expected for the site, erosion is minor with some instability and deposition (USDI and USDA 2000). Plant community B is called the “pre-threshold community”. It is critical that this community be recognized and strategies implemented to prevent further regression. Although this community can improve to either Community A or HCPC through successional processes, further disturbance will result in regression to a lower state. Once Community B regresses to a lower state, normal successional processes are restricted.

Pathway CP 1.1 - 1.2
Community 1.1 to 1.2

Non-prescribed grazing, drought and/or a cessation of the natural fire regime will cause regression from HCPC to Community A.

Pathway CP 1.2 - 1.1
Community 1.2 to 1.1

Favorable growing conditions, the implementation of prescribed grazing, or periodic fire will move Plant Community A to the HCPC. This succession can occur within a couple of years.

Pathway CP 1.2 - 1.3
Community 1.2 to 1.3

Community A will regress to Community B under non-prescribed grazing, prolonged drought, or an extended period without fire. The rate of regression varies with the kind, intensity, frequency, and duration of the disturbances. Severe drought may cause retrogression within a couple years.

Pathway CP 1.3 - 1.2
Community 1.3 to 1.2

The Clay Pan 10-14” p.z. ecological site is resilient within the Reference State. Prescribed grazing and/or a period of favorable precipitation will induce succession from Community B Community A within a reasonable time frame.

State 2
State 2: Plant Community C

Community 2.1
State 2; Plant Community C

Short Cool and Warm Season Perennial Grasses, Half-shrubs and Lower Successional Forbs, Medium Height Cool Season Grasses, Cactus and Annual Species Present, Increased Bare Ground, and Decreased Total Annual Production.

Resilience management. Plant Community C is characterized by a significant reduction in species composition by weight of medium-height, cool season grasses. Wheatgrasses contribute about 25 percent of total annual growth. Plants produce few seed heads and are low in vigor. This community is dominated by low-successional grasses and sedges. Blue grama, prairie junegrass, other short grasses, sedges and clubmoss contribute about 50 percent of the total annual production. Clubmoss cover is usually most severe on soils with loamy A and E horizons. Broom snakeweed, fringed sagewort and pricklypear cactus are conspicuous in the community. Japanese brome, cheatgrass, annual forbs (fanweed and pepperweed), and curlycup gumweed will be present. Total annual production is reduced about 75 percent from levels in the HCPC. Percent composition of forbs and shrubs are highly variable from place to place and from year to year in this community. Variability is apparent in productivity and occurrence of individual species. Litter cover averages about 10 percent, which is a large reduction relative to site potential. Water flow patterns are numerous and there is moderate active pedestalling. In communities that are not characterized with clubmoss, bare ground is moderately to much higher than expected. There is moderate soil loss or degradation in interspaces with some degradation beneath plant canopies. Compared to the HCPC, there has been a structural shift from medium height to short grasses, and a functional shift from cool to warm season plants. Reproductive capability of cool season plants is greatly reduced relative to recent climatic conditions.

Transition T1A
State 1 to 2

However, Community B is much less resistant to perturbations than Community A. Lower production, lower vegetative cover, less litter, and increased bare ground contribute to increase Community B’s susceptibility to disturbance. Extended drought and non-prescribed grazing can lead to further retrogression (State 2). The threshold separating Communities B and C appears to be the functional threshold, below which the type, amount, and pattern of vegetation is often inadequate to prevent accelerated soil erosion.

Restoration pathway R2A
State 2 to 1

Plant community C is a steady state. It is resistant to significant succession. Blue grama, other short grasses, sedges and clubmoss form a competitive community. The adverse soil conditions and a theorized inadequate seed bank of species found in State #1 greatly restrict potential for succession to State #1. When clubmoss cover is more than 20-25%, succession is not expected to occur within a reasonable length of time. However, significant succession may occur with the combination of prescribed grazing, implementation of the natural fire regime, and an extended period of favorable moisture. This potential is depicted with the dashed line in the state and transition diagram. In comparison to more common ecological sites with moderately deep to deep soils (ie, Silty 10-14” p.z., Clayey 10-14” p.z., and Sandy 10-14” p.z.), annual production on a Clay Pan 10-14” p.z. ecological site is about 30% less. Therefore, vegetation response to mechanical treatments and range seeding will be less than the response expected on the higher producing sites (NRCS Conservation Practice Standard 548-1).

Additional community tables

Table 9. Community 1.1 plant community composition

Group	Common name	Symbol	Scientific name	Annual production (kg/hectare)	Foliar cover (%)
Grass/Grasslike
1	Rhizomatous Wheatgrasses			202–437
	western wheatgrass	PASM	Pascopyrum smithii	101–202	–
	thickspike wheatgrass	ELLAL	Elymus lanceolatus ssp. lanceolatus	101–202	–
2	Cool-season Bunchgrasses			252–504
	green needlegrass	NAVI4	Nassella viridula	101–202	–
	bluebunch wheatgrass	PSSP6	Pseudoroegneria spicata	101–202	–
	needle and thread	HECO26	Hesperostipa comata	50–101	–
3	Warm-season Bunchgrasses			50–101
	alkali sacaton	SPAI	Sporobolus airoides	50–101	–
4	Miscellaneous Grasses			0–101
	Grass, native	2GN	Grass, native	0–50	–
	blue grama	BOGR2	Bouteloua gracilis	0–50	–
	plains reedgrass	CAMO	Calamagrostis montanensis	0–50	–
	threadleaf sedge	CAFI	Carex filifolia	0–50	–
	Sandberg bluegrass	POSE	Poa secunda	0–50	–
	prairie Junegrass	KOMA	Koeleria macrantha	0–50	–
	squirreltail	ELEL5	Elymus elymoides	0–50	–
	sand dropseed	SPCR	Sporobolus cryptandrus	0–50	–
Forb
5	Dominant Forbs			10–50
	American vetch	VIAM	Vicia americana	10–50	–
6	Clovers			20–101
	purple prairie clover	DAPU5	Dalea purpurea	10–50	–
	white prairie clover	DACA7	Dalea candida	10–50	–
7	Miscellaneous Forbs			0–50
	scarlet globemallow	SPCO	Sphaeralcea coccinea	0–50	–
	aster	ASTER	Aster	0–50	–
	prairie thermopsis	THRH	Thermopsis rhombifolia	0–50	–
	pussytoes	ANTEN	Antennaria	0–50	–
	bastard toadflax	COUM	Comandra umbellata	0–50	–
	milkvetch	ASTRA	Astragalus	0–50	–
	spiny phlox	PHHO	Phlox hoodii	0–50	–
	Forb, native	2FN	Forb, native	0–50	–
	scurfpea	PSORA2	Psoralidium	0–50	–
Shrub/Vine
8	Dominant Shrubs			29–135
	Nuttall's saltbush	ATNU2	Atriplex nuttallii	6–50	–
9	Miscellaneous Shrubs			0–73
	silver sagebrush	ARCA13	Artemisia cana	0–50	–
	greasewood	SAVE4	Sarcobatus vermiculatus	0–50	–
	prairie sagewort	ARFR4	Artemisia frigida	1–50	–
	big sagebrush	ARTR2	Artemisia tridentata	1–50	–
	Shrub (>.5m)	2SHRUB	Shrub (>.5m)	0–50	–
	plains pricklypear	OPPO	Opuntia polyacantha	0–17	–

Interpretations

Animal community

Livestock Management
The Clay Pan 10-14” p.z. ecological site is suited for livestock grazing. However, prescribed grazing management is needed. Forage production is somewhat limited by soil characteristics. Many species occurring in State #1 are palatable to livestock, which makes the communities susceptible to heavy stocking and season long grazing. The cool season medium height grasses are generally selectively grazed, giving the short grasses a competitive advantage. Grazing during early spring may result in soil compaction. Any additional factor reducing infiltration and increasing runoff on this site is a management concern. Shorter grazing periods and adequate periods of rest following grazing are needed to facilitate plant regrowth and accumulate litter.
This ecological site has a component of shortgrass species, as do most other sites in the northern mixed prairie. The shortgrasses usually increase with grazing pressure and decrease with deferment or prescribed grazing. However, succession is not guaranteed in the Northern Great Plains. Sampling four-year old ungrazed exclosures and grazed areas with 35% utilization, Vogel and Van Dyne (1966) found essentially the same basal cover of grasses, sedges, forbs, litter and bare soil on protected and grazed sites. They concluded that four years was too short of a time for cover to change significantly. Hofmann and Ries (1989) observed similar results following a four-year study in North Dakota. Even after 41 years of exclosure, changes in species composition can be relatively small when the site is in the dry, low production portion of northern mixed prairie (Brand and Goetz, 1986). They concluded that site characteristics limited the development of potential vegetation with the exclusion of grazing, but the potential impacts of prescribed grazing on succession were not discussed. The Clay Pan 10-14” p.z. ecological site is not as productive as the sites evaluated by Vogel and Van Dyne, Hofmann and Ries, or by Brand and Goetz. Therefore, range managers should recognize the environmental limitations of this site. Prescribed grazing management is always a good recommendation. Furthermore, chiseling of these soils is common in Phillips County and can be very successful given the right conditions.

Wildlife Interpretations
The HCPC associated with this ecological site provides diverse and valuable wildlife habitat. This site often occurs as a mosaic with other ecological sites, thus creating “ecotones” that serve as a magnet for many species of wildlife. Antelope and mule deer prefer grazing this site because of the Nuttall saltbush and diversity of forage species. However, the landscape does not provide thermal and escape cover. The bare ground limits the potential of the site for upland birds and for ground-nesting birds.
This ecological site becomes less valuable for deer and antelope when plant diversity declines with regression. For example, the disappearance of either the tall cool season grasses or warm season grass would shorten the length of the “green forage” season. The increase of blue grama, clubmoss, hoods phlox, etc. is also associated with the loss of palatable forbs. These changes tend to adversely impact foraging opportunities for deer, antelope, upland birds, etc. Community C has very little value for most wildlife species because of insufficient vegetative structural diversity, residual grass carry-over and litter cover.

Plant Preferences by Animal Kind
Refer to NRCS Field Office Technical Guide, Section IIE, General Information, for tables displaying plant preferences by livestock and wildlife.

Hydrological functions

Water is the main factor limiting vegetative production on this site. Soil components in this ecological site are normally classed into Hydrologic Group D. These soils have a medium to very high runoff potential, with hydrologic runoff curves of 89 to 80. Field investigations are needed to adjust the runoff curves when plant communities deteriorate from the Historic Climax Plant Community. Areas where ground cover is less than 50 percent have the greatest potential to have reduced infiltration and higher runoff.

Recreational uses

This site provides hunting opportunities for upland game species.

Wood products

This site has no significant value for wood products.

Other information

This site ecological site is not highly resistant to disturbances. Species diversity is adversely affected by season long continuous grazing and by heavy stocking. Medium height grasses are replaced by short grasses. The number of structural/functional groups is reduced with regression from the HCPC. The amount of solar energy that is captured and converted to carbohydrates for plant growth is reduced in State #2. A reduction in total vegetative growth results in less potential vegetation that can be transformed into litter. Litter reductions result in less infiltration, and more runoff and soil erosion.

Supporting information

Inventory data references

Data Source Number of Records Sample Period State County
SCS-Range-417 (#503) 1 1991 MT Phillips
ECS-1
Modified Double Sampling 0
USDA-SCS-MT 1981 Technical Range Site Description

Site Description Revisions
The 2005 Clay Pan 10-14” p.z. ecological site description replaces earlier dated versions of Clay Pan 10-14” p.z. descriptions in Rangeland Resource Unit 52XC. This 2005 revision incorporates the State and Transition Model theory, additional data on site productivity, and an improved understanding of many rangeland health indicators.

Site Description Approval
This ecological site description is approved with the understanding that it is no more than another step in our continual effort to update the NRCS technical guide. In order to facilitate the process, NRCS field personnel are encouraged to forward existing information and/or new data that can be used to improve the utility of this site description. Please forward the information and data to the State Rangeland Management Specialist.

Other references

Brand, M.D. and H. Goetz. 1986. Vegetation of exclosures in Southwestern North Dakota. J. Range Manage. 39:434-437.
Briske, D. D., S. D. Fuhlendorf, and F. E. Smeins, 2005. State-and-transition models, thresholds, and rangeland health: a synthesis of ecological concepts and perspectives.
Rangeland Ecol. Manage 58:1-10.
Frost, C. C. 1998. Presettlement fire frequency regimes of the United States: a first approximation. Pages 70-81. in Teresa L. Pruden and Leonard A. Brennan (eds.). Fire in ecosystem management: shifting paradigm from suppression to prescription. Tall Timbers Fire Ecology Conference Proceedings. No. 20. Tall Timbers Research Station, Tallahassee, FL.
Heitschmidt, R. K., K. D. Klement, and M. R. Haferkamp. 2005. Interactive effects of drought and grazing on Northern Great Plains rangelands. Rangeland Ecol. Manage. 58:11-19.
Hofmann, L. and R.E. Ries. 1989. Animal performance and plant production from continuously grazed cool-season reclaimed and native pastures. J. Range Manage. 42:248-251.
USDA and USDI. 2000. Interpreting indicators of rangeland health. Technical Reference 1734-6.
Vogel, W.G. and G.M. Van Dyne. 1966. Vegetation responses to grazing management on a foothill sheep range. J. Range Manage. 19:80-85.

Contributors

Loretta J. Metz 03/19/2005
Kirt Walstad
Marji Patz

Approval

Kirt Walstad, 1/24/2024

Acknowledgments

Dr. John Lacey 02/23/2005
Maxine Rasmussen, Area RMS, Glasgow, MT
Jon Siddoway, Area RMS, Great Falls, MT
Rick Bandy, Area RSS, Great Falls, MT
Greg Snell, Area RSS, Glasgow, MT

Rangeland health reference sheet

Interpreting Indicators of Rangeland Health is a qualitative assessment protocol used to determine ecosystem condition based on benchmark characteristics described in the Reference Sheet. A suite of 17 (or more) indicators are typically considered in an assessment. The ecological site(s) representative of an assessment location must be known prior to applying the protocol and must be verified based on soils and climate. Current plant community cannot be used to identify the ecological site.

Author(s)/participant(s)	Loretta Metz, Maxine Rasmussen, Jon Siddoway
Contact for lead author	Area Rangeland Management Specialist, Glasgow Area Office, MT Reference Site used? NO
Date	05/04/2005
Approved by	Kirt Walstad
Approval date
Composition (Indicators 10 and 12) based on	Annual Production